DISH – Town Commissioner William Sciscoe Monday called for Congress to investigate how the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality and the Railroad Commission have handled air quality concerns in the Barnett Shale.
During the town council meeting Monday night, Sciscoe pressed representatives from TCEQ, who came from Austin to answer questions about air quality studies currently in progress, when they knew about problems in Dish. Agency representatives told the crowd -- town leaders, about two dozen residents and several industry representatives -- they knew about the problems this summer.
But residents there have complained to both the industry and the state agencies ever since pipeline and compression facilities began expanding there in 2006, town leaders said. Town commissioners voted in May to pay for an air quality study. Results released in October showed troubling levels of neurotoxins and carcinogens in the air.
Sciscoe handed Susana Hildebrand, chief engineer for the air quality division, copies of letters where TCEQ inspectors had come out to investigate some of those complaints, calling them “a whitewash.”
“The field agent stood in my driveway and said he smelled gas at the time, but when the report was written, it said, ‘no odor was detected at this time,’” Sciscoe said. “The replies to our complaints are, ‘there’s nothing to worry about here.’”
He repeated the town’s call to cease and desist operations on Strader Road, where five companies treat and compress millions of cubic feet of gas from 11 high-pressure pipelines, until it could be proven that no harm was coming to the community.
“I’ve asked for a safety stand down and have had little reply from the industry,” Sciscoe said. “There is ample evidence that you all are in bed with the industries you are here to regulate, and all levels of the agencies are involved.”
He questioned why TCEQ hadn’t used its regulatory muscle and pulled permits.
“Here in the city, if they don’t follow the permit, we jerk the permit,” Sciscoe said.
While Hildebrand acknowledged she hadn’t seen the reports Sciscoe handed her, she told him she didn’t appreciate the characterization of ethical conflicts. She underscored the agency’s commitment to tackle the problem.
“We hear you,” Hildebrand said. “You’re our top priority now.”
Hildebrand told the crowd that energy companies install compression and other equipment with a “permit by rule” – essentially, companies claim their equipment emits less than 25 tons per year of volatile organic compounds.
“It’s an old rule,” Hildebrand said. “It was conceived of at a time when these weren’t being put in neighborhoods.”
Hildebrand described the studies that had already been conducted, including 40 hours of sampling and 15 hours of infra-red camera recordings, as well as sulfur sampling. The data is being checked for quality and will be turned over to the toxicology department by the end of December, she said. That report should follow in January.
In addition, Hildebrand and fellow air quality employee, Keith Sheedy, described a 7-day, 24-hour study that would be combined with 12 months of production data, to produce a comprehensive look at emissions in the area.
TCEQ would contract for that study, Hildebrand said, using money from the natural gas industry.
Many residents, some of whom suffer from health problems, told TCEQ representatives that they didn’t trust them any more and believed an industry-funded study would be tainted.
“How is that fair?” said Megan Collins. Collins said she developed a debilitating and mysterious neurological condition while living in Dish.
Longtime resident Chuck Paul, who’s lost the use of much of his land to eminent domain from multiple, redundant pipelines, acknowledged that the community’s attacks on state officials may seem personal.
“You see, we’ve been attacked for a long time,” Paul said.
Many residents said the community was out of time and needed relief now. Mayor Calvin Tillman said he was home Sunday washing his vehicles when the air smelled so bad, it started burning in his nose and lungs.
He went inside and called TCEQ and got bounced around and was eventually told to call the Texas Railroad Commission.
Hildebrand told Tillman that the managers were embarrassed when they heard about that and that they would change how complaint calls would be managed.
Near the end of the meeting, resident Robert Draper stood up, cowboy hat in hand, and asked whether, over the long term, the process meant the companies would stop polluting, or just get permission to keep polluting.
“Is there ever going to be a chance that this is a safe area and benzene-free?” Draper asked. “There’s no way anyone will buy my property now. We’re all stuck here until we die.”
PEGGY HEINKEL-WOLFE can be reached at 940-566-6881. Her e-mail address is
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
.